Hybris vs. Magento vs. Demandware: Which is the better option?

Posted by piksel on Nov 14, 2018 4:30:00 PM
brooke-lark-609899-unsplash-1

It has never been more important for retailers to have a strong e-commerce platform. By 2040, it’s predicted that 95 percent of purchases will be facilitated online.

But, with so many platforms to choose from, how do you know which is the best fit for your business?

There are a diverse range of choices on the market, but in this blog we’ll compare three of the most popular: Hybris, Magento and Demandware.

While every provider boasts its own unique benefits, the decision to commit to an e-commerce platform must revolve around your specific business needs and use cases. Ask yourself:


  • Are you a B2B or B2C retailer?
    While many platforms support B2C, only certain providers support the complexities of a B2B system.

  • What is your budget?
    Some platforms suit large scale, global brands with bigger budgets, while others are designed with smaller brands in mind.

  • Do you have the internal team to support your platform?
    While some platforms are fully managed and require little technical maintenance, others require a committed internal team.

To help you out, we’ve listed the pros and cons of these leading platforms and offered our personal recommendations on each.

Demandware

Demandware is a cloud-based platform launched in 2004. With a strong reputation among global retailers, Demandware is the platform of choice for well-known brands such as:

  • Adidas
  • Loreal
  • Crocs
  • Gopro
  • Birkenstock
  • Puma
  • Nyx Cosmetics

In terms of install-base, Demandware is the most widely used B2C SaaS eCommerce platform. The majority of Demandware's customers are B2C retailers, however they are currently developing Omni-Channel capabilities.  

The good

  • Highly scalable
    Due to Demandware cloud-based features, size isn’t a limitation. The software can scale up or down on-demand and in-line with seasonal fluctuations.

  • Built-in disaster recovery
    Demandware offers high availability, even during peak traffic.

  • Easy to support
    Thanks to its effective UI, Demandware has a simple set-up. You can implement it in a shorter time frame than other platforms, and it doesn’t require a crack team of technical support staff.

The bad

  • High costs
    Demandware is not the best fit for small to medium retailers. Their target clients are highly competitive brands, some with annual sales of up to £400 million. Therefore, Demandware retailers pay high rates for their service.

  • Not suitable for B2B retailers
    Demandware is a B2C platform and not suited for complex B2B pricing or promotions use-cases. The platform is unable to meet bulk ordering or customisation requirements.

  • Revenue share
    Part of Demandware’s contractual obligation is they take a license fee based on a percentage commission of your online sales, between 0.75% up to 1.25%. While the Demandware argues this means they are invested in their consumer’s success, it may not suit every retailer.

SAP-Hybris

Magento

Magento is an open-source e-commerce platform. Popular among small to medium B2C retailers, Magento has a diverse, yet less recognisable range of clients than Demandware:

  • Sigma Beauty
  • JCB
  • Just for Men
  • Osprey London
  • Paul Smith
  • Bookpal
  • Riese & Müller

Magento currently holds 10.85 percent of the e-commerce software market share and is the most widely adopted open sourced platform.

The good

  • Mobile friendly
    Magento understands the importance of mobile-friendly configuration for e-commerce, allowing users to reach a larger customer base.

  • Wide range of features
    Magento is suitable for a wide range of use cases. Its open-source add-ons make it easy to manage multiple stores, and support a range of locations, languages and currencies.

The bad

  • Difficult to support
    Getting support for open-source platforms can be challenging. Magento is a complex system that requires a certain level of database and web-server expertise. Only businesses with a robust team of in-house technical staff should consider Magento as a primary option.

  • Slow loading time
    Due to its flexible architecture, Magento has a time-consuming set-up and imports data at a slow rate.

  • High costs
    While the community version of Magento is free, the platform costs upward of £11,000 for enterprises. For the premium service, the annual cost is approximately £40,000. And this figure doesn’t include third party fees.

Hybris

Hybris is considered a leader by the Digital Commerce Gartner Magic Quadrant, which is pictured below.

Hybris-vs-magento-vs-demandware


Acquired by German giants SAP in 2013, Hybris has a global footprint of more than 500 customers, including:

  • Samsung
  • O2
  • Vodafone
  • Audi
  • Carphone Warehouse
  • 3M
  • Oakley

The good

  • Designed with B2B business in mind
    Hybris understands the unique requirements of B2B retailers and boasts that ‘only Hybris delivers B2B user experience on par with the best B2C websites’. This is due to the company’s ability to enter new markets and adapt to different business models quickly.

  • Omni-channel capabilities
    As of 2019, 67 percent of e-commerce sales are predicted to come from mobile. Hybris is committed to creating great UX across all channels, including desktop, mobile and tablet and doesn’t limit a business to one channel, broadening profit opportunities.

  • Simple to support
    Due to Hybris’ use of Java, the platform is easy to maintain. As most IT professionals have a solid understanding of JavaScript, retailers needn’t hire expensive developers.

The bad

  • Slow implementation
    Hybris’ somewhat old-fashioned architecture means their release life-cycles can be slow - in some cases up to 24 months to deliver.

  • Expensive implementation
    Hybris architecture relies on technology paradigms derived in the early 2000s. For this reason, implementation can be complex and expensive, requiring large technical teams to maintain.

  • Difficult to scale
    Rigid architecture also makes it difficult to scale in line with seasonal fluctuations.

Enter DC2

Hybris is best suited to large-scale, omnichannel operations. It's also the only logical solution for B2B retailers and is capable of handling the majority of large scale enterprise use-cases. This is why Hybris is our platform of choice. However, we understand it’s not without its drawbacks.

Hybris’ Java stack architecture means the platform doesn’t deploy or scale as efficiently as some of its competitors. To rectify this, we’ve have built DC2: our stable, scalable, high-performing AWS-based solution.

Key benefits of our DC2 platform include:


  • Rapid deployment of SAP Hybris on to AWS

  • Autoscaling for seasonal fluctuations

  • More agile release cycle with small incremental changes

  • Cost optimisation

  • 24/7 managed system

Build your empire on solid ground

The world of e-commerce is diverse and there isn’t a fix-all solution for every retailer. When choosing your platform, you must weigh up each provider’s benefits and disadvantages, and pick a platform that can support your unique use case.

For us, Hybris is a natural choice. Its omnichannel capabilities, B2B focus and proven track record make it a leading solution. However, we there are still flaws to address – ones we’ve been keen to overcome with our DC2 solution.

While Hybris isn’t perfect, customers using the platform see an average 40 percent increase in online sales. On top of this, one of our clients, The White Company have experienced a further 20 percent sales increase since implementing DC2.

We think these numbers speak for themselves. Although companies like Demandware and Magento offer a good starting point, for true customisation and innovation, DC2 and Hybris provide the perfect platform on which to build your eCommerce empire.  

SAP-Hybris

Topics: ecommerce

Related posts

Build a scalable e-commerce platform: The White Company case study

There are so many thousands of e-commerce platforms online. But what does real success look like in the online shopping industry? In this blog we...

Read more
How to maximise revenue with SAP Hybris

The retail business operates in peaks and troughs. Whether it’s the summer sales, back to school or ‘Black Friday’, some days are busier than...

Read more